The City of Sarasota’s Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club, 801 North Tamiami Trail, consists of a barrel vaulted auditorium and an attached two-story, semi-circular recreation club. The building was constructed in 1937; a second floor was added to the recreation club portion in 1940. The building, designed by Sarasota architects Thomas Reed Martin and Clarence A. Martin, features architectural elements and decorative motifs of the Art Deco and Moderne styles.
The foundation consists of a concrete perimeter wall and interior piers with a ventilated crawl space. The walls are constructed of masonry and concrete block and finished on the exterior with smooth stucco; the walls are plastered on the interior. The barrel vaulted roof reportedly was originally sheathed with a thin layer of copper although the architect’s specifications called for galvanized corrugated sheathing. Three existing asphalt shingles were installed around 1976. Three rectangular, louvered roof vents protect above the roof ridge.
The Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club was constructed as part of an 11-acre recreational complex, originally called the Civic Center or Bayfront Park. The building has been a visual landmark for residents and tourists as they approached Sarasota from the north, along the principal automobile route into town – the Tamiami Trail.
The Civic Center complex has been modified over the years. When in opened in 1939, in addition to the Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club there were six tennis courts, forty shuffleboard courts, and several lawn bowling courts. A clubhouse at the west end of the shuffleboard courts provided shower and locker accommodations. South of the Auditorium, on land reclaimed from marshes, were two small fresh water lakes. Winding walkways led through the landscaped grounds. According to newspaper accounts, comfortable benches were scattered about the grounds where one could “while away the hours, in rest and peaceful meditation.” In December 1940, an illuminated cast stone fountain was installed in front of the Municipal Auditorium.
Much of the original site was altered by the widening of the Tamiami Trail in the late 1950s, extensive land fill along the shoreline in the mid-1960s, and the construction of several other civic buildings When the Tamiami Trail was widened, the fountain was removed and placed in storage where it awaited renovation and relocation.
In the early 1990s many of the recreational facilities were removed to provide space for additional parking. The original club house, shuffleboard courts, tennis courts, and badminton courts were removed. Of the three remaining lawn bowling courts only the center one is original. A modern shelter, running east-west, is placed between the south and center lawn bowling courts.
Exterior – Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club
The Municipal Auditorium faces east. This façade is accentuated by a dramatic arched stucco and glass block façade with a central, slightly recessed, entrance. Seven pairs of tall, narrow glass block panels are set between thin projecting pilasters, echoing the curve of the parapet and barrel vaulted roof beyond. Stepped pilasters flank the central bay, which is surmounted by a parapet with a slightly stepped crown. A decorative, geometric, horizontal cast stone frieze, below the glass block panels, highlights this façade. The Art Deco frieze consists of a semi-circular sunburst pattern set within the triangular spaces of a continuous saw tooth pattern. The frieze extends across the east façade, the east ends of the north and south facades, and is broken by the extended flat canopy roof over the main (east) entrance.
Sarasota’s Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club, at 801 North Tamiami Trail, was built in 1937 as a Progress Works Administration project. It was the first project in the development of a bay front civic center that included facilities for shuffleboard, tennis, and lawn bowling. The Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club is significant as a reflection of the role of government in Sarasota during the Depression years. Civic leaders raised private funds to qualify for additional federal funding of the project. The facility is also significant for its importance in Sarasota’s recreational history. During World War II the complex accommodated social activities for military personnel stationed nearby. The Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Center is also significant as an architecturally distinguished, Art Deco/Moderne Public Works Administration design by Sarasota architects Thomas Reed Martin (pictured right) and Clarence A. Martin. Modified during the 1970s, the Municipal Auditorium’s original interior and façade were restored in 1992 and 1993. The original function has remained constant.
In 1885 the town of Sarasota was platted in a grid-pattern of streets and avenues by a British-owned corporation called Florida Mortgage and Investment Company Limited. The town was incorporated in 1902. The completion of a railroad line the following year marked a significant turning point for Sarasota, for it expanded the city’s commercial base and brought new residents and tourists. A 1911 bond issue financed the city’s first water works and sewer system. The population of the city was an estimated 1,276 in 1912. By 1913, Sarasota had two banks, telephone service, and electricity. In the 1920s, as the Florida Land Boom reached a feverish pitch, the entire Sarasota area underwent tremendous growth and a number of new subdivisions were platted.
The Boom ended in 1926 with a devastating halt in statewide real estate sales, preceding the 1929 Stock Market Crash and the nationwide Great Depression. By late 1933, 26% of Floridians were receiving public assistance. Like other Florida municipalities, Sarasota’s tax base had dwindled and all city operations were hindered. The city sought federal assistance under provisions of the Federal Emergency Relief Act (FERA) enacted by Congress in 1933. Sarasota also endeavored to take advantage of other relief programs enacted by the Roosevelt administration, including the Public Works Administration (PWA) and the Works Projects Administration (WPA). The function of the PWA was to construct public buildings and structures. The role of the WPA was to employ the country’s unemployed millions. States were required to financially contribute to PWA projects. During the initial four years of the program, Florida was able to complete 26 institutional buildings. This funding was insured by a 1935 legislative act which made $1 million dollars available for “skilled labor and materials for public works.”
In a small brochure, PWA Administrator Harold Ickes summarized his administration’s accomplishments on the occasion of the fourth anniversary of the program in June, 1937. As part of the “largest construction program in history,” he cited the completion of new schools, libraries, hospitals, bridges, waterworks, power plants and many other types of public facilities. The PWA accounted for four-fifths of all construction nationwide and kept thousands off relief rolls. Ickes called the PWA the “first Federal slum clearance and low-rent housing program in America.” He noted that since 1933, 70% of the schools, 62% of the hospitals, and 52% of the waterworks had been PWA construction projects. Ickes’ report concluded, “The Public Works Administration [record] shows that President Roosevelt has brought us out the depression. I am convinced that the country not only realizes this now but that appreciation of what PWA had done will grow with the years.”
Local communities bore the major share (usually 66%) of the cost of a PWA project. The PWA lent the balance on public works projects indebtedness at 4%, furnishing a market for municipal bonds. As Ickes noted in his four-year summary, the “widespread popularity” of PWA projects depended upon local taxpayers.
In addition to institutional building projects, the PWA encompassed diverse projects across Florida. The projects included road paving, wharf construction, construction of schools, military barracks, a library, airport control towers, and drainage canals. By December of 1936, the statewide monthly newsletter reported the graduation of several dozen students from the Household Training Project, who were to be gainfully employed “in private homes as cooks and maids.” A hurricane bulletin was in production at the University of Florida; homemaking conferences for women were held at Camp Roosevelt in Ocala; and a project for an airport at Venice was completed by July of 1936.
Sarasota’ Municipal Auditorium fell within a broad range of non-federal PWA-funded projects. Such projects, awarded to cities, counties and states, included city and town halls, courthouses, fire and police stations, jails, armories, social and recreational buildings, archives, farm buildings and markets, parks and swimming pools. A total of 1,628 such projects across the country were to be completed by March of 1939. The Municipal Auditorium was one of the 707 auditorium/gymnasium projects. Throughout the State of Florida, 232 non-Federal PWA projects had been undertaken, 149 were completed and 83 were under construction by 1939, at a total cost of $32 million dollars.
Sarasota actively sought the assistance of various government programs during the Depression. In the spring of 1935, Mayor E.A. Smith (pictured right) travelled to Washington, D.C. as a representative of the City and the Chamber of Commerce to lobby for support of Sarasota’s projects. He reported to a special City Council meeting on his return that he had been assured that the project to extend water mains in the southern part of the city would be approved, but that details for other projects needed to be completed before presentation to Federal authorities. Those projects included a water main in the north part of the city, a Municipal Auditorium, and recreational facilities.
In 1936 Sarasota acquired 40 acres adjacent to the new Tamiami Trail/Broadway Avenue and restricted the property to park, playground, and recreational use. In July of 1937, Sarasota Mayor E.A. Smith announced his plan to construct, with the assistance of the PWA, “one of the finest recreation centers in the south” on this property. Mayor Smith estimated the cost at $100,000.
However, just as the Municipal Auditorium project was about to get underway in Sarasota, the PWA was beginning to curtail its activities. Administrator Ickes estimated that it would require approximately two years to finish “a billion dollars worth of projects.” A Roosevelt plan before Congress proposed to reorganize the executive branch of the Federal Government and to create a permanent Department of Public Works with Cabinet status, “to which the Federal Emergency Administration of Public Works may turn over its tasks and its trusteeship.” Desperate to continue the program, the Director of Florida’s Construction Program for state institutions wrote Florida’s Congressional representatives. Congressman J. Hardin Peterson, who described himself as “a member of the PWA bloc in the House,” along with U.S. Senators Claude Pepper and Charles O. Andrews were among those who responded to Floridians’ urging that the program be continued. The Congressional delegates pledged to support the Hayden Amendment to the relief bill providing for the extension of PWA funds.
Sarasota was suffering from the economic hard times. In January of 1937, the City Council authorized one of a series of refunding bonds to readjust the City’s indebtedness, explaining that the outstanding indebtedness and future interest accruals would “impose upon the City too great a burden for it to meet.” Even finding the necessary funds to finance the PWA projects was becoming a difficult task. PWA projects underway in Sarasota by early 1937 included a $250,000 sanitary sewer project for Sarasota Heights subdivision. Bonds financed 55% of the project and a 45% federal government grant provided the balance. A Sarasota Waterworks project had been contracted, but insufficient available PWA funds had prevented the work.
Because the city lacked sufficient funds to ensure acceptance of the Auditorium project, in March of 1937 a group of prominent Sarasota businessmen met at the home of Karl Bickel (pictured right) and agreed to loan the city $10,000. Bickel was formerly President of United Press and Chairman of the Board of Scripps Howard Radio Company. Present at the meeting were Sarasota’s most prominent civic leaders and representatives of her major institutions. The stellar individuals at the meeting included Benton W. Powell, publisher of the Sarasota Tribune, and President of the Palmer National Bank; Samuel W. Gumpertz, Senior Vice President and General Manager of Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus; J.J. Williams, Jr., City Attorney; Ralph Caples, a railroad and advertising executive; George Thacker, President of the Chamber of Commerce; building contractor Frank Logan, who was serving as a fiscal Agent of the City in connection with bond refunding; and George D. Lindsay, founder, owner, and editor of the Sarasota Herald.
At the City Council’s regular meeting of April 5th, Benton W. Powell appeared to represent the group and explain their interest in the Auditorium project. Their $10,000 loan together with the government portion of about $25,000, would at least make a substantial start on the project. Powell suggested an interest rate of 5% per annum that could be paid from revenue to be derived from the tennis courts, auditorium, or other activities. The Counci approved acceptance of the loan and extended a vote of thanks and appreciation to the group who had shown such interest in this proposal.
Dr. John R. Scully, a veterinarian, had been Health Officer for Sarasota and Manatee counties for a decade. He served twice as Commissioner of Public Works, from 1929 through 1939. During his tenure, Sarasota obtained vitally needed public improvements at the time when the City’s credit was exhausted. Scully managed to obtain the materials needed to carry on numerous projects financed in part by government agencies, including the reconstruction of the new Ringling Causeway and Bridge; the construction of a new bridge over Hudson Bayou; construction of seawalls around City Hall; and the paving of many streets. Scully also supervised the construction of the Municipal Auditorium and the Lido Beach Casino.
After accepting the loan from the civic leaders, the City Council authorized $200 for Scully to obtain tentative plans and specifications on at least part of the community park in order to get work started at the earliest possible date. Scully was instructed to submit tentative plans or sketches to the Council and Planning Board.
The Sarasota City Council Minutes of April 19, 1937, show that architects Clarence A. and Frank Martin were involved in the design of the Municipal Auditorium and adjacent park. By May 24, 1937, the City Council had passed a resolution outlining the financial commitments of the city for the Auditorium project. The city would apply for WPA funding only on the Auditorium; would furnish the necessary skilled labor not available form the local relief rolls; would buy all necessary materials not furnished by the WPA; and would assume the full responsibility of completing the project if WPA funds were not available for that purpose.
Groundbreaking preceded the production of plans. Mayor E.A. Smith announced that the “first spadeful of earth” would be turned on July 13, 1937. The day before, Commissioner of Public Works Scully had announced that the WPA “had finally approved” the project. The groundbreaking ceremony, headed by Mayor Smith, was attended by a contingent of local dignitaries and civic officials. The Sarasota Kiwanis Club voted to attend “in a body,” and challenged other groups to follow suit. The Sarasota Tourist Club, represented by Dr. Charles C. Montague, announced its plans to use the Auditorium to produce a “bigger and better tourist crop.” The Winter Haven Symphony Orchestra, “one of the state’s finest musical units,” was announced as a possible tenant of the new building.
In his speech at the groundbreaking, Mayor Smith noted that Sarasota had outgrown its meeting places and praised the Auditorium as a structure “sufficient for all needs for years to come.” He predicted the building would be as beautiful in the twenty-five years as when completed. He also praised the seventeen men who three months earlier had guaranteed the Sponsors’ Contribution, naming them individually. Mayor Smith acknowledged that completion of the ambitious civic center project might occupy several years.
Thirteen days after the groundbreaking, Engineer Freeman H. Horton and architect Thomas Reed Martin provided schematic designs for boathouses, walkways, pools and gardens. Building plans dated August 7, 1937 were by Thomas Reed Martin and Clarence A. Martin. The Sarasota Herald said the auditorium would be built under the direction of engineers and senior WPA supervisors, J.C. Bravo and E.H. Knight.
The Auditorium opened on February 23, 1938, eight months after the groundbreaking and at the height of the 1937-38 tourist season. A reported 3,000 attended the first event, the Sara de Soto Pageant Ball, dancing to Glen Gray’s Casa Loma Orchestra. Strategically-placed decorations disguised the fact that the ornamental plaster on the stage was unfinished. The surrounding grounds also remained incomplete.
City Recreational Director, Charles L. Herring, noted that while many Florida resort areas lacked “good, wholesome recreation,” Sarasota’s complex would offer a variety of recreational outlets. Name bands would be brought to Sarasota during the season to play for dances at the Auditorium. There would also be flower shows, symphony concerts, and exhibitions. Facilities for shuffleboard, tennis, lawn bowling, badminton, and horseshoe pitching would be provided, and golf enthusiasts would have a putting green. A softball diamond was also contemplated. Lawn bowling was an especially popular activity among Sarasota’s citizens and winter visitors. The Sarasota Lawn Bowling Club was organized in 1927.
The grounds of the complex were platted with hundreds of palm trees. Dozens of guava trees, palmettos, Spanish bayonet and the stately royal palm, which for years had grown unmolested on the property were closely guarded and maintained as part of the grounds beautification.
A second floor was added to the Recreation Club portion of the Municipal Auditorium building and dedicated in January, 1940. This was a gift from Mr. and Mrs. John Tuttle Chidsey. Chidsey was the retired president of the board of the Veeder-Root Company of Hartford. He and his wife, Ida Cook Chidsey, retired from Bristol, Connecticut to become seasonal residents of Sarasota in 1932. Chidsey was a member of the Kiwanis Club and First Presbyterian Church, and served for several years as president of the “Tourist or Recreation Club.” In 1941, he was named Sarasota’s Outstanding Citizen.
A reported 1,000 attended the official opening of the Recreation Club expansion, presided over by newly-reelected Mayor E.A. Smith. Activities included a shuffleboard tournament, tennis and archery exhibits, and a grand ball.
The recreation club was designed with an encircling terrace to take advantage of the vista to the west, overlooking Sarasota Bay. The second floor addition contained a lounge area with bamboo-type furniture, a recreation room, and a men’s card room. The card room featured a sliding partition to make two rooms if necessary. There was also an office for the Board of Directors.
During wartime, the Municipal Auditorium was featured in postcards as the “Army and Navy Club,” and was used as a meeting place for enlisted men and local girls who danced to the tunes of a “massive jukebox,” and were cooled by “big floor fans.”
In the 1960s, the Municipal Auditorium was renamed the Civic Center Exhibition Hall. Its functions were modified with the construction of a Performing Arts Hall (Van Wezel) on newly-dredged and filled shoreline to the west.
Art Deco/Art Moderne Style
The Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club incorporates elements of both the Art Deco and the 1930s Streamlined Moderne styles. Art Deco, inspired by the 1925 Paris Exposition des Artes Decoratif, was a means of expressing architectural modernity in the late 1920s. Characteristics of the style included: smooth wall surfaces, usually of stucco, towers or other vertical projections extending above the roof line; symmetrical facades; and a unique form of ornamentation consisting of zigzags, chevrons, sunbursts, spirals, and/or stylized motifs of plants and animals.
New industrial and technological developments in the early 1930s led to the evolution of the Streamlined Moderne style which also featured smooth wall surfaces that were frequently curved and usually stuccoed. In contrast to the verticality of the Art Deco design, the Streamlined Moderne style emphasized the horizontality of the building through the use of bands of contrasting finish materials and bands of windows. Glass block and steel railings for stairs and balconies were frequently utilized. This style reflected the interest in the streamlined designs in vogue for ships, airplanes, and automobiles. It also incorporated some elements of the emerging International Style which evolved from the philosophy developed at the Bauhaus Design School. The Bauhaus, founded in Germany in 1919 by Walter Gropius, was concerned with simplicity and the tenet that “form follows function.”
Architects and Engineers
Thomas Reed Martin was 71 when he and Clarence A. Martin designed the Municipal Auditorium/Recreation Club. A Wisconsin native, he had worked in Chicago as a draftsman and woodworking company manager. While with that firm he also studied architecture and construction. He was retained in 1911 by the famed Chicagoan, Mrs. Potter Palmer, to remodel her newly acquired winter estate on Sarasota Bay. Martin thereafter made Sarasota his residence. By his own estimate, he designed more than 500 houses in the Sarasota area over a forty-year period.
Clarence A. Martin was approaching his 75th birthday as the Municipal Auditorium plans were drawn. Martin was a five-year resident of Sarasota and a member of the Chamber of Commerce. A Ohio native, he studied at Cornell University and received a doctorate degree from Colgate University in 1918. Martin had joined the Cornell faculty in 1895 as a professor of architecture. From 1908-1919 he served as Dean of the College of Architecture. Martin was a Fellow of the American Institute of Architects and was founder and former Secretary-Treasurer of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture.
The principal engineer of the Municipal Auditorium project was Freeman H. Horton, the son of Manatee-Sarasota pioneers. He had graduated from Harvard and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 1918. Horton was a structural engineer for many public works including the Union Terminal in Cincinnati, Ohio; the Bayshore Drive and seawall in Tampa; and the Mayport Naval Base near Jacksonville, Florida. He served in the State Road Department from 1917 to 1921. He also designed locks and bridges for the Cross-Florida Barge Canal, until construction was halted in 1935. Horton began working for the City of Sarasota in March of 1937, where his expertise and skills were essential in getting projects approved by the PWA. Plans dated September 21, 1937, identify J.C. Hartness as the designer of the wooden trusses used in the Auditorium. Biographical information on Hartness could not be located.
You must be logged in to leave a comment.
The Craig Residence is located in the Lido Shores neighborhood, an area of the city now recognized for offering a high concentration of architecture associated with the "Sarasota School." Philip Hiss created this enclave of great architecture as landowner, developer, amateur architect, and patron of the arts. He designed or commissioned houses to respond to the coastal Florida climate and employ progressive principles of design: goals that the Craig Residence addresses successfully.Read More »
The Arthur T. and Loretta P. Nelson House is located at 4017 Swift Road on the northeast corner of Swift Road and Forest Lane. There are two historic resources on the property: a single story Frame Vernacular Style house with Craftsman influences, and a single-bay, frame garage. The garage was constructed first in approximately 1925, and lived in while the house was constructed in 1926.Read More »
The Charles Picket home located at 1731 Bay Street is a one-story stucco-over-tile block frame "bungalow" built in 1924. The Spanish style bungalow consists of two bedrooms, one bath, living and dining rooms, kitchen, front sunroom and sleeping porch. A dozen masonry vents allow for air circulation. The roof is flat with a built-up parapet with five exterior copper drain spouts and a stuccoed brick chimney appears on the west facade.Read More »